I-864 Defense: Settlement or Litigation—your attorney should be ready and willing for both ?

Why choosing an attorney who is prepared to negotiate and litigate matters.

When facing a claim under Form I-864, one of the most important decisions a sponsor must make is whether to negotiate a settlement or defend the claim through litigation. Both approaches have advantages and disadvantages, and the right decision depends on the facts, the available evidence, the potential financial exposure, and the likelihood of success.

At Mulder Law Office, we have resolved I-864 disputes before lawsuits were filed, negotiated settlements that allowed the parties to move forward with their lives, and successfully defended sponsors at trial. Our experience has demonstrated that neither settlement nor litigation is appropriate in every case.

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Settlement

Settlement is often the most practical resolution of an I-864 dispute. It can eliminate the expense, uncertainty, and emotional burden of litigation. Most importantly, a properly structured settlement may provide finality, allowing the parties to resolve their contractual obligations and move forward.

However, settlement also has disadvantages. A sponsor may agree to pay more than the plaintiff could establish in court simply to avoid litigation.

Before agreeing to a settlement, sponsors should understand what the plaintiff must prove, the amount of potential liability, and whether the proposed agreement provides meaningful protection against future claims.

A reasonable settlement should reflect the merits of the claim, not merely the plaintiff's demand.

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Litigation

Litigation provides an opportunity to challenge the plaintiff's claims through discovery, examination of financial records, motions, and, when necessary, trial.

An I-864 contract is enforceable, but that does not mean every plaintiff is entitled to recover the damages demanded. The plaintiff must establish the amount of any legally recoverable shortfall under the applicable Federal Poverty Guidelines.

Litigation may reveal income or other qualifying support that was not considered in the plaintiff's calculations. It may also establish that the sponsor's obligation has terminated by operation of law.

The disadvantages are equally important. Litigation can be expensive, lengthy, and unpredictable. Even a successful defense may involve substantial attorney fees and costs, and an adverse judgment may expose the sponsor to damages and an award of attorney fees.

For these reasons, litigation should be pursued with a clear understanding of the evidence, the legal issues, and the financial risks.

What Our I-864 Cases Have Demonstrated

Mulder Law Office has represented sponsors in cases illustrating why a thorough evaluation is essential before deciding whether to settle or litigate.

Flores v. Flores — Idaho

The Court determined that the I-864 obligation had terminated during the marriage by operation of law. The plaintiff's claimed income shortfall was also challenged through a detailed examination of the financial evidence. The defendant prevailed without an award of damages or plaintiff's attorney fees.

California — Judgment for the Defendants

Following a bench trial, the Court entered judgment for the defendants under California Code of Civil Procedure § 631.8. Although the I-864 contract was enforceable, the plaintiff failed to establish damages by proving that her support from all sources fell below 125% of the applicable Federal Poverty Guidelines.

Chicago — Breach Established, Damages Not Proven

In a recent federal case, the Court found a breach of the I-864 contract but determined that the plaintiff had not established the amount of the claimed income shortfall. The question of damages remained unresolved.

These cases illustrate an important distinction: The existence of an enforceable I-864 contract, or even a finding of breach, does not automatically establish the amount of damages owed.

Choosing the Right Strategy Begins with Choosing the Right Attorney

An effective I-864 defense begins with understanding the plaintiff's financial circumstances, examining all legally relevant sources of income and support, determining whether the obligation remains enforceable, and evaluating the evidence supporting the claim.

The attorney's role is to assess the advantages and risks of settlement against those of litigation and recommend a strategy that serves the client's interests.

At Mulder Law Office, we believe that settlement is often the best outcome, particularly when it provides a final resolution. However, the decision to settle should be informed by a thorough understanding of the available defenses and the potential outcome of litigation.

The strongest negotiating position is often the demonstrated willingness and ability to defend the case in court.

Our approach is to prepare each case for the possibility of litigation while remaining open to reasonable settlement opportunities.

Prepared to Negotiate. Ready to Litigate. Committed to Your Defense.

Mulder Law Office, P.A. — Representation of Defendants in Form I-864 Contract Disputes

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case depends on its particular facts, evidence, and applicable law.

Kyndra L Mulder, Esquire Google User

Kyndra L Mulder, Esquire, is a licensed attorney for almost 40 years. She specializes in representing American citizens who are being sued by the beneficiary of an I-864 Affidavit of Support that they signed. Ms. Mulder handles cases in Federal courts throughout the United States and acts a consultant or expert witness in State court cases through out the United States.

https://MulderLawOffice.com
Previous
Previous

I-864 Defense: The Doctrine of Unclean Hands, Marriage Fraud, and Financial Misconduct

Next
Next

I-864 Enforcement in Blue States vs. Red States