What Is the Doctrine of Unclean Hands?
The doctrine of unclean hands is an equitable principle that may prevent a party from obtaining relief when that party has engaged in dishonest or wrongful conduct directly related to the claim before the court.
In simple terms, a party seeking relief should not be permitted to benefit from misconduct connected to that claim.
However, applying this doctrine to enforcement of Form I-864 presents unique legal issues because the contract is governed by federal immigration law.
Marriage Fraud Is Generally Not a Defense to I-864 Enforcement
Many sponsors believe that proving their spouse entered the marriage fraudulently will relieve them of their I-864 obligations. Generally, that is not the case.
The Form I-864 is a contract between the sponsor and the United States government. The sponsored immigrant is an intended third-party beneficiary entitled to enforce the contract.
Congress established the affidavit-of-support requirements to protect the American taxpayer from bearing the financial burden of supporting sponsored immigrants. Allowing sponsors to escape their obligations solely because of misconduct by the immigrant would undermine that statutory purpose.
In Belevich v. Thomas, 17 F.4th 1048 (11th Cir. 2021), the Eleventh Circuit held that equitable defenses, including unclean hands, could not excuse the sponsor's statutory I-864 support obligation.
But the fact that marriage fraud does not directly defeat enforcement of the I-864 does not mean that marriage fraud is without legal consequences.
Marriage Fraud May Lead to Termination of the I-864 Obligation
Marriage fraud may establish grounds for immigration enforcement, including removal from the United States.
Where credible evidence establishes that the immigrant entered the marriage to evade immigration laws, the sponsor should consider presenting that evidence to the appropriate immigration authorities.
At Mulder Law Office, when supported by credible evidence and appropriate to the representation, we prepare reports documenting suspected marriage fraud for submission to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
A finding of marriage fraud may lead to immigration proceedings and ultimately to the loss of lawful permanent resident status.
Under 8 C.F.R. § 213a.2(e)(2), an I-864 obligation terminates by operation of law when the sponsored immigrant ceases to hold lawful permanent resident status and departs the United States, subject to the regulation's requirements.
Thus, marriage fraud may provide an indirect path to terminating the sponsor's future obligation, even though it is generally not a direct defense to a civil I-864 lawsuit.
A fraud finding or the commencement of removal proceedings does not itself terminate the obligation. The required terminating event must actually occur.
Financial Misconduct: Concealed Income, Tax Evasion, and Misrepresentations
At Mulder Law Office, our investigation of suspected misconduct extends beyond allegations of marriage fraud.
In I-864 litigation, a plaintiff's actual financial circumstances are central to determining whether damages are owed.
Potential areas of investigation include:
Unreported employment: Working for cash or otherwise receiving income that is not disclosed in financial records or tax returns.
Concealed financial support: Failing to disclose money, housing, or other assistance received from family members, friends, or third parties.
Misrepresented loans: Characterizing deposits or financial resources as loans without adequate documentation establishing their nature.
False representations of residence: Claiming to reside in the United States while actually residing in Canada or another country, particularly when those representations affect government benefits or immigration status.
Government benefits fraud: Knowingly providing false financial or residency information to obtain benefits.
These circumstances may raise questions of fraud, credibility, and the accuracy of the plaintiff's claimed damages.
Although such conduct does not automatically establish an unclean-hands defense to the I-864 obligation, it may be highly relevant to whether the plaintiff has proven the amount of support allegedly owed.
An enforceable contract does not relieve the plaintiff of the burden of proving legally recoverable damages.
The Plaintiff's Financial Evidence Must Be Examined
The I-864 obligation generally requires the sponsor to maintain the sponsored immigrant at 125 percent of the applicable Federal Poverty Guidelines.
Determining whether a shortfall exists requires examination of the plaintiff's income and other financial support recognized under the applicable law.
At Mulder Law Office, we examine bank records, employment history, claimed loans, financial assistance, and other relevant evidence. We challenge unsupported calculations and investigate discrepancies between the plaintiff's claimed financial circumstances and the available records.
A plaintiff's failure to establish the amount of a claimed shortfall can be significant even when the contract remains enforceable.
Misconduct May Have Consequences Beyond the Civil Lawsuit
Suspected tax evasion, immigration fraud, or government benefits fraud may warrant separate investigation by the appropriate governmental authorities.
When credible evidence supports such allegations, Mulder Law Office evaluates whether a report to the appropriate authorities is warranted and, where appropriate, assists clients in preparing and submitting supporting documentation.
These matters are separate from the civil I-864 enforcement action. Any investigation, prosecution, immigration proceeding, or determination of wrongdoing rests with the responsible governmental authority.
Importantly, not every instance of financial misconduct will affect immigration status, and not every immigration violation results in termination of the I-864 obligation.
Conclusion: A Complete I-864 Defense Requires a Complete Investigation
The doctrine of unclean hands has limited application to enforcement of the I-864 contract. Marriage fraud generally does not excuse a sponsor's contractual obligation, and equitable defenses may be unavailable under controlling federal law.
Nevertheless, evidence of marriage fraud, concealed income, tax evasion, or other financial misrepresentations should not be ignored.
Such evidence may undermine the plaintiff's claim for damages, expose misconduct requiring separate investigation, or lead to immigration proceedings that ultimately result in a statutory terminating event.
At Mulder Law Office, we believe that defending an I-864 claim requires a thorough examination of both the plaintiff's financial circumstances and the continuing enforceability of the contract.
The sponsor's obligation is defined by law. So is the plaintiff's burden to establish the damages claimed.
Mulder Law Office, P.A. — Defense of Form I-864 Sponsors
This article provides general legal information and does not guarantee the availability of any particular defense or outcome.

